Carnage Pump Pre-Workout
vs Pump Shotty Non Stim Pre Workout
Ingredient & Score Comparison
Last updated: Feb 2026
PwrRanks Verdict
Score Comparison
Objective scores based on ingredient dosing — 0 to 1 scale
Pump Shotty Non Stim Pre Workout's formula has 2g L-Tyrosine and 600mg Alpha-GPC, which contribute to a higher focus score.
Carnage Pump Pre-Workout delivers more performance per dollar than Pump Shotty Non Stim Pre Workout — based on how both products compare to the broader pre-workout market.
Ingredient Comparison
Carnage Pump vs Pump Shotty Non Stim — dosing per serving
| Ingredient | Objective | Carnage Pump | Pump Shotty Non Stim |
|---|---|---|---|
| Caffeine Yield | Energy | — | 2mg |
| L-Citrulline | Pump | 6g | 10g |
| Betaine Anhydrous | Pump | 2.5g | 5g |
| Arginine Silicate | Pump | 1.5g | 1.5g |
| Taurine | Pump | 1g | — |
| Pine Bark Extract | Pump | — | 250mg |
| AstraGin | Pump | 25mg | 50mg |
| Sodium | Pump | 45mg | — |
| L-Tyrosine | Focus | — | 2g |
| Alpha-GPC | Focus | 600mg | 600mg |
| DMAE | Focus | 500mg | — |
| L-Theanine | Focus | — | 200mg |
| Beta-Alanine | - | — | 3.2g |
| L-Norvaline | - | — | 400mg |
| VasoDrive-AP | - | 254mg | — |
| EndoFlo | - | 150mg | — |
| C-Glycosyl Xanthone | - | 100mg | — |
| Black Pepper Extract | - | 5mg | — |
Who Should Buy Each
Matching products to training goals and stim tolerance
Choose Carnage Pump If…
- ✓You want performance without stimulants — perfect for training at any time
- ✓You do not like the Beta-Alanine tingles
Choose Pump Shotty Non Stim If…
- ✓You're caffeine-sensitive or train in the evening
- ✓You want the edge taken off stimulant intensity — focused without feeling wired
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about these two pre-workouts
Both are low-stim or stimulant-free (1mg or less per serving).
More Comparisons
Closest alternative to Carnage Pump
Ninja Swole Stim Free vs Carnage Pump
Closest alternative to Pump Shotty Non Stim
Bare Knuckle vs Pump Shotty Non Stim
Popular Pump matchup
Pump Daddy vs Transparent Labs Stim-Free
How PwrRanks Scores Pre-Workouts
Our methodology
PwrRanks scores every pre-workout by analyzing its ingredient label algorithmically. We generate four objective scores — Energy, Pump, Focus, and Value — that reflect what's in the tub, not how the product is marketed. Value scores are calculated using live pricing data to reflect real cost-per-serving at time of comparison.